The Squid Nebula (OU4): a giant outflow hiding in the Flying Bat

One of the most punishing astrophotography targets to capture is the Squid Nebula (OU4). In 2011, Nicolas Outters was photographing a faint red emission region in Cepheus when his oxygen filtered frames turned up something that had no business being there. A vast, two lobed shape stretched across the field, absent from his hydrogen and sulfur data, showing only in the light of doubly ionized oxygen. He called it le Calamar, the squid. Today it is know as OU4 or the Squid Nebula.

The discovery

Outters was imaging SH2-129, the Flying Bat Nebula, with a Takahashi FSQ-106 refractor and a CCD camera, working through hydrogen alpha, sulfur, and oxygen filters. The oxygen channel, where he had stacked about 12.5 hours, revealed a large structure the other frames did not show. He took it to the French astrophysicist Agnes Acker in Strasbourg, who confirmed the strong oxygen emission, and the discovery was reported in 2012. The object entered the catalogs as OU4, the fourth nebula Outters had found, and more formally as PN G 098.6+07.9.

Sh2-129 (Flying Bat) and OU4 (the Squid) in narrowband, 131 hours. Image by Ram Samudrala, CC BY 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

What and where it is

The Squid sits inside SH2-129 in Cepheus, a hydrogen emission region not far from the much larger IC 1396. In a color image the Flying Bat is the red hydrogen cloud, and the Squid is the teal shape near its center, a blue green that comes almost entirely from OIII. It is large on the sky, running over a degree along its long axis and roughly fifteen arcminutes wide, which puts the long dimension at several times the apparent width of the full moon. It is also extremely faint, and on most equipment it appears only in OIII filtered data.

A spectrum that points to something hot

The shape, a central disk like body with two opposite lobes, reads like a bipolar planetary nebula, the kind of shell a dying sun like star throws off. The spectrum reinforces the strangeness. The OIII emission is on the order of twenty times stronger than the hydrogen beta line, a high excitation that calls for a very hot ionizing source. For years that was where the story stopped, a striking bipolar nebula of unknown distance and uncertain origin.

The current best explanation

A 2014 study by Romano Corradi and colleagues in Astronomy and Astrophysics gathered the evidence for a different picture. Rather than a foreground planetary nebula, OU4 appears to lie within SH2-129 itself, around 2,300 light years away, and to move with the surrounding gas. In that reading it is a giant bipolar outflow driven by HR 8119, a hot triple star system near the center of the squid. The lobe tips show arc shaped fronts of brighter OIII that resemble the bow shocks seen where stellar outflows collide with surrounding material, and the lobes would measure about 47 by 8 light years. At that distance the whole structure spans close to 50 light years. The origin is not settled beyond doubt, but the outflow interpretation is the one the kinematics currently favor.

Why it is so hard to photograph

Two things make OU4 a punishing target. It is faint, and it is large. Faint, because the OIII surface brightness is low enough that it takes many hours of oxygen band data to bring out, and the images that show it well are generally built from tens of hours. Large, because at over a degree it does not pack its light into a small bright core the way a compact planetary does. Add a bright sky and a small aperture and the oxygen signal can sit under the noise for a long time before it climbs out. The Squid has earned a reputation as a test of patience rather than of equipment.

Imaging it from a backyard

A smart telescope like the DWARF 3, at 35mm and f/4.3, frames the whole object with room to spare, so composition is never the problem here. Depth is. The limiting factor is how much OIII you can accumulate against the sky background, which is why this object rewards long total integration far more than it rewards focal length or resolution.

The Flying Bat Nebula Sh2-129 in red hydrogen across the field of the Squid Nebula OU4, captured with a DwarfLab DWARF 3 smart telescope, Duo-Band filter, 17 hours 33 minutes integration, Bortle 6. Stellar Studio output with capture details and dwarfastro.com overlaid.
Sh2-129, the Flying Bat Nebula, across the field of OU4, the Squid Nebula. DWARF 3 · Duo-Band · 17h 33m · Bortle 6. Stellar Studio output.

For a worked example of how faint that really is, I spent 17 hours 33 minutes on OU4 with a DWARF 3 and put the oxygen signal through a significance test. What the numbers showed, and what it would take to actually detect the Squid, is in the data story.

The final verdict on whether the Dwarf 3 can capture the Squid Nebula is that it cannot. Read the story here.

Frequently asked questions

What is the Squid Nebula?

A very faint, two lobed nebula in Cepheus, designated OU4, that glows almost entirely in doubly ionized oxygen. It sits inside the larger hydrogen region SH2-129, the Flying Bat Nebula.

Who discovered OU4, and when?

French amateur astrophotographer Nicolas Outters, in 2011, while imaging SH2-129. His oxygen frames showed a large structure that was absent from his hydrogen and sulfur data.

Is OU4 a planetary nebula?

Its bipolar shape looks like one, and that was the early assumption. A 2014 study argues instead that it is a giant bipolar outflow inside SH2-129, driven by the hot triple star HR 8119, although its nature is not fully settled.

How big is the Squid Nebula?

On the sky it runs over a degree along its long axis, several times the apparent width of the full moon. If it lies within SH2-129 at about 2,300 light years, it is physically close to 50 light years end to end.

Why is OU4 so hard to photograph?

Its OIII surface brightness is very low and the object is large, so the signal spreads thin and rises above the sky noise only after many hours of oxygen band data, often tens of hours.